Spoilers in comment 6, some idiot joined just to try and spoil the book, reported but be aware
- lukeo44
Top comments
sarb_singh1980 to bobbymartini
21 Jun 1610#4
She never had a 'skin colour' in the book - the pigmentation of her skin is not mentioned once. Hollywood's adaptation of the novels chose to have a person of a certain heritage/colour and other may choose to have another. JKR herself states this and the fact she is happy with a directors choice of 'black' or 'white' actors playing the part - so long as character is true to the script. One of the key tenants if the book is that its not the difference of how we look that makes us good or bad, but our actions, words and character.
bobbymartini
21 Jun 164#9
Yes....it was white....the same as it was in all 8 films. All official visual representations of Hermione have, up to this point, been white. The fact she is black in the play annoys me - nothing to do with race, everything to do with continuity. J K Rowling saying she never stated a skin colour is BS. As an advisor on all of the films including a producer credit on the final two, she "signed off" the whole look of the HP universe. She approved Jim Kay's illustrations in the illustrated Philosophers Stone book. Changing it now, just so she can meet so called 'Diversity' quotas is pathetic.
I am not a racist. I would have the same issue if the character of 'Cho Chang' was played by a non asian actor in a future production. Continuity, for me, is very important.
bobbymartini
21 Jun 163#2
It's the script......the one where Hermione completely changes her skin colour.
All comments (20)
nadhaw
21 Jun 16#1
Books £10 or over are free delivery anyway.. Is that a proper book though or the script of the play?
bobbymartini
21 Jun 163#2
It's the script......the one where Hermione completely changes her skin colour.
sarb_singh1980 to bobbymartini
21 Jun 1610#4
She never had a 'skin colour' in the book - the pigmentation of her skin is not mentioned once. Hollywood's adaptation of the novels chose to have a person of a certain heritage/colour and other may choose to have another. JKR herself states this and the fact she is happy with a directors choice of 'black' or 'white' actors playing the part - so long as character is true to the script. One of the key tenants if the book is that its not the difference of how we look that makes us good or bad, but our actions, words and character.
andrewrobinson1970
21 Jun 161#3
It's the script of the play.
As Jk doesn't have time to write it as a novel but we all want to know what happens.
This will be £10 or less everywhere when released. Potentially biggest book launch of the year.
I find WH Smith's very competitive online, usually always the cheapest and they pay UK taxes!
XOXJADEXOX
21 Jun 16#7
I preordered it with water stones same price
Harryisme
21 Jun 161#8
Well I don't know about the illustrations, but on the front cover of the Prisoner of Azkaban, Hermione has the same skin tone as Harry. A book that came out before the movies.
I find the whole argument silly, I think it's obvious JKR intended Hermione to be white, but at the end of the day she doesn't care what the skin tone is as long as the charactor is done justice.
bobbymartini
21 Jun 164#9
Yes....it was white....the same as it was in all 8 films. All official visual representations of Hermione have, up to this point, been white. The fact she is black in the play annoys me - nothing to do with race, everything to do with continuity. J K Rowling saying she never stated a skin colour is BS. As an advisor on all of the films including a producer credit on the final two, she "signed off" the whole look of the HP universe. She approved Jim Kay's illustrations in the illustrated Philosophers Stone book. Changing it now, just so she can meet so called 'Diversity' quotas is pathetic.
I am not a racist. I would have the same issue if the character of 'Cho Chang' was played by a non asian actor in a future production. Continuity, for me, is very important.
Opening post
Spoilers in comment 6, some idiot joined just to try and spoil the book, reported but be aware
- lukeo44
Top comments
I am not a racist. I would have the same issue if the character of 'Cho Chang' was played by a non asian actor in a future production. Continuity, for me, is very important.
All comments (20)
As Jk doesn't have time to write it as a novel but we all want to know what happens.
This will be £10 or less everywhere when released. Potentially biggest book launch of the year.
I'd wait.
£10 at WH Smith, free delivery to store and 5% TCB:
http://www.whsmith.co.uk/products/harry-potter-and-the-cursed-child---parts-one--two-special-rehearsal-edition-parts-i--ii---the-official-script-book-of-the-original-west-end-production/9780751565355
I find WH Smith's very competitive online, usually always the cheapest and they pay UK taxes!
I find the whole argument silly, I think it's obvious JKR intended Hermione to be white, but at the end of the day she doesn't care what the skin tone is as long as the charactor is done justice.
I am not a racist. I would have the same issue if the character of 'Cho Chang' was played by a non asian actor in a future production. Continuity, for me, is very important.