After failing to get in for a good few hours earlier today, I managed to get some game time from 2am-4am (my sleeping pattern is screwed).
Overall, it's not bad, but it's not great either. If it wasn't for the beta I probably would have ended up purchasing it. Now? Definately not.
1. It's the same old run and gun scenario, and objectives are the last thing on the majority of players minds. I would have preferred it if they set up a deathmatch, or team deathmatch as that's what's going on at the moment.
2. The weapons, whilst being locked until you earn rewards, are too cartoony for my liking. I remember when COD1 / UO first came out, and the realistic sounds, recoil and such from weapons like the Kar98 were spot on. These Battlefield 1 weapons are a joke, and incredbly difficult to master for some reason. I ended up sniping most of the time. It's the same old story. You need to be in someone's face to kill them CQB style.
3. The planes are just a disaster. The old BF2 planes / choppers were much more enjoyable than this. Hell, even the desert combat mod for the original was better than this. VERY hard to control the planes. Flew 3 times, crashed each time.
4. Team chat is almost non existant. You can press the K key to chat but nothing comes up on the screen. If I press it again, it shows up briefly, but it would be much nicer if you typed and it was shown on screen. I never once saw any replies on my screen to convo's I made. Really, really stupid.
I won't go into it anymore, but it's definately not for me. I really wanted to like it, but I got so **** off with it, I just turned the computer off. I'll uninstall it when I wake up. I thought EA would have changed a few things but it's just BF4 with a new skin.
All comments (27)
GrahamFairham
1 Sep 161#1
Agree, its the same on PS4 still more fun than any post COD 2 offering (this may get the COD kids dummies out sorry). Hopefully they will improve it the same way they did with BF4 - like all modern games these days. Marketing benefits of patching
shakey82
1 Sep 16#2
This may seem silly but do you need PSN+ to play it or is it like Doom where you can play online without it
shakey82
1 Sep 161#3
This is commonly the case with Battlefield games when they first come out and after a few major updates after they have refined it and got public data off forums they turn it into a great game. I hated bf4 when it first went beta but now i like it
JibbJab
1 Sep 161#4
Wow - someone who feels the same about the BF franchise as me! BF2 was sublime, BF1942 a game-changer (no pun intended), as was Codename Eagle before that. For me, the BF franchise died at BF3, the last version I played which to be fair was a fun game. CoD/UO were massive in the day and I still occasionally play now, great fun. BF for me now is the same as CoD is - frequently churning out a new version to keep the cash cow alive. My FPS of choice is now Red Orchestra/Rising Storm which graphically isn't as good as BF (but still decent), but the gameplay is deep and if you can get on a server with good team players, makes for a very rewarding game. There is also a Vietnam release coming for it soon (Rising Storm 2). I won't be trying BF1, each to their own but from what I've seen it's not for me.
TehJumpingJawa
1 Sep 161#5
BF2 is 11 years old, and is in all the ways that matter, a better game than all that followed.
Sad state of affairs :disappointed:
Is this game still doing nothing but lip service to the ww1 theme?
thelagmonster
1 Sep 161#6
Tried it, hugely disappointing. BF has gone downhill since 3.
hotfinder
1 Sep 16#7
Free trial to justify that my Argos COD IW misprice purchase was a winner? Yes please! :sunglasses:
But on a serious note, I know they're completely different styles of games. Being a COD 2 and COD WAW fan (and old Battlefield games too) I was actually hoping EA hit a home run on this but from the comments it looks like it hasn't. Oh well. Maybe it will be better when I actually buy it for ~£10 after all the patches. The games industry must be taking a hit on this late patching strategy surely?
darkstryder360
1 Sep 16#8
Objectives aren't important to most it seems. I was sat in a light tank in Rush defending an outpost. Got 24 kills in the end because all the other team wanted to do was sit back and snipe.
So I just kept picking them off and they couldn't do anything to me.
And when I try and use the Medic class, the skip revive doesn't encourage you to revive anyone as they just want to get back in the action, and the health indicator is incredibly small! I just throw out bandages left right and centre hoping someone needs it.
Enjoy it but it is the same old format which for someone like me with short attention span can get boring very quick.
Like Battlefront.
FinderOfDeals
1 Sep 16#9
Does anyone else have problems getting BFH to load in Windows 10, but fixed it? It used to play, but doesn't any more for me.
Gynx
1 Sep 161#10
To me it looks like a cross between Day of Defeat with an awful lot of Wolfenstein multiplayer Enemy Territory thrown in (the version that was canned and released as a multiplayer only) with the Battlefield gloss, or simplicity.
Playing it just makes me want to go back to playing Enemy Territory but that's a guilty addition I'd rather not go back to.
mohsin0310
1 Sep 16#11
can't find it on ps4 store..where can i download it from?!?
kick_u_in_the_nuts
1 Sep 16#12
hardly any distructable enviroments on it - which is what made the early bf
nutmeister
1 Sep 16#13
Aiming is awful atm. Am sure they will patch this for final release but still not good even at beta level.
LotusJas
1 Sep 161#14
It worked today. Looked & sounded fantastic (4k, Ultra, 50fps minimum).
But did not enjoy repeatedly being killed :wink: Really needed a solo practice mode. Did not enjoy it. Not buying it, based on this.
superivanho
2 Sep 16#15
Anyone remembers the original Battlefield 1942 mod - Battlefield 1918? I found it more fun than Battlefield 1...
sammy1255
2 Sep 16#16
same here, atleast not on mine
usernamenotavailable
2 Sep 16#17
See comment #10
usernamenotavailable
2 Sep 16#18
see comment #10
usernamenotavailable
2 Sep 16#19
Not sure if BFH means BF1
Yesterday servers had some problems, but I've had no problems running it under Win10 without having to tweak anything
stefromuk
2 Sep 16#20
all the houses can be destroyed!
it's only 1 map from the trailer there's village type maps and I'm sure you'll be able to destroy stuff there :smiley:
chapchap
2 Sep 161#21
It has grown on me big time and I will be buying it.
Jammy212 to chapchap
3 Sep 16#22
Same for me aswell. Really enjoying it actually! Have to say though that I like Conquest much better than Rush. :smiley:
SamuraiHQ to chapchap
3 Sep 16#24
So... I decided to give this game another shot, but I was getting so frustrated at the BS that was going on I simply left, and uninstalled it. I am so disappointed with EA, but I can't say I'm surprised. There is absolutely nothing new here. The trailer led you to believe this was going to be the best game ever. I'm sure it should have held the caption "not in game footage" somewhere on there though.
It's just TOO cartooney for my own liking. When I get a kill, it's more often from luck than anything else. Perhaps I'm used to coming in first every game from CoD. Hell, I'm still playing CoD 4: Modern Warfare, and the mods that go with it. But the weapons, aiming, recoil and movements are just that more realistic. I jumped out of a burning plane earlier. I somehow survived. Must be that soft soft sand.
Like I said. Very disappointed. It's like it was aimed for kids somehow. It just feels dumbed down beyond belief. I'm getting sniped from 600m away, almost like there's no drag on the bullets. Everyone knows, the further out you are you have to compensate for trajectory of bullets. Not least wind, but no game has really gone that far.
CoD hasn't faired much better in recent times either. The last one I purchased was Ghosts and it was uninstalled in a couple of hours. There's just not much competition around these days, but people will still buy crap if there's only crap on sale. I won't be one of them. Such a shame. A damn shame.
Hope you all have a much better experience with this game. I feel like I've wasted 6 hours of my life.
wozukSilencer to chapchap
3 Sep 16#25
did a noob just get slaughtered for 6 hours by a 8 year old :laughing:
FinderOfDeals
3 Sep 16#23
BFH is Battlefield:Hardline. Thanks anyways :smiley:
SamuraiHQ
3 Sep 16#26
Pretty much. But I wouldn't call myself a noob. I've probably been playing online games (FPS) longer than you've been alive. The game is crap. Any other game my stats tell a completely different story. It's not even fun. People aren't going to their objectives (why they still continue to make CTF mode is a mystery). There's not even voice chat capability. This is 2016 for crying out loud. People may say "oh it's just a beta" but these things should be in the beta already. It'll be another 9 months before everything is patched up to make it worthwhile and by then it'll be half the price. In any case, I still won't be buying it.
DCFC79
3 Sep 16#27
Works fine for me, there's a wait of a minute or 2 for waiting for it to join a game and it finds 1 to join.
![Fresh Breakfast Meat Box (Using code) @ Campbells Meat [Haggis / Lorne Sausage / Bacon / Black Pudding & More]](/images/topics/208684_1.jpg)
![[Xbox One] Q. u. b. e: Director's Cut on Deals with Gold](/images/topics/208716_1.jpg)
Opening post
Overall, it's not bad, but it's not great either. If it wasn't for the beta I probably would have ended up purchasing it. Now? Definately not.
1. It's the same old run and gun scenario, and objectives are the last thing on the majority of players minds. I would have preferred it if they set up a deathmatch, or team deathmatch as that's what's going on at the moment.
2. The weapons, whilst being locked until you earn rewards, are too cartoony for my liking. I remember when COD1 / UO first came out, and the realistic sounds, recoil and such from weapons like the Kar98 were spot on. These Battlefield 1 weapons are a joke, and incredbly difficult to master for some reason. I ended up sniping most of the time. It's the same old story. You need to be in someone's face to kill them CQB style.
3. The planes are just a disaster. The old BF2 planes / choppers were much more enjoyable than this. Hell, even the desert combat mod for the original was better than this. VERY hard to control the planes. Flew 3 times, crashed each time.
4. Team chat is almost non existant. You can press the K key to chat but nothing comes up on the screen. If I press it again, it shows up briefly, but it would be much nicer if you typed and it was shown on screen. I never once saw any replies on my screen to convo's I made. Really, really stupid.
I won't go into it anymore, but it's definately not for me. I really wanted to like it, but I got so **** off with it, I just turned the computer off. I'll uninstall it when I wake up. I thought EA would have changed a few things but it's just BF4 with a new skin.
All comments (27)
Sad state of affairs :disappointed:
Is this game still doing nothing but lip service to the ww1 theme?
But on a serious note, I know they're completely different styles of games. Being a COD 2 and COD WAW fan (and old Battlefield games too) I was actually hoping EA hit a home run on this but from the comments it looks like it hasn't. Oh well. Maybe it will be better when I actually buy it for ~£10 after all the patches. The games industry must be taking a hit on this late patching strategy surely?
So I just kept picking them off and they couldn't do anything to me.
And when I try and use the Medic class, the skip revive doesn't encourage you to revive anyone as they just want to get back in the action, and the health indicator is incredibly small! I just throw out bandages left right and centre hoping someone needs it.
Enjoy it but it is the same old format which for someone like me with short attention span can get boring very quick.
Like Battlefront.
Playing it just makes me want to go back to playing Enemy Territory but that's a guilty addition I'd rather not go back to.
But did not enjoy repeatedly being killed :wink: Really needed a solo practice mode. Did not enjoy it. Not buying it, based on this.
Yesterday servers had some problems, but I've had no problems running it under Win10 without having to tweak anything
it's only 1 map from the trailer there's village type maps and I'm sure you'll be able to destroy stuff there :smiley:
It's just TOO cartooney for my own liking. When I get a kill, it's more often from luck than anything else. Perhaps I'm used to coming in first every game from CoD. Hell, I'm still playing CoD 4: Modern Warfare, and the mods that go with it. But the weapons, aiming, recoil and movements are just that more realistic. I jumped out of a burning plane earlier. I somehow survived. Must be that soft soft sand.
Like I said. Very disappointed. It's like it was aimed for kids somehow. It just feels dumbed down beyond belief. I'm getting sniped from 600m away, almost like there's no drag on the bullets. Everyone knows, the further out you are you have to compensate for trajectory of bullets. Not least wind, but no game has really gone that far.
CoD hasn't faired much better in recent times either. The last one I purchased was Ghosts and it was uninstalled in a couple of hours. There's just not much competition around these days, but people will still buy crap if there's only crap on sale. I won't be one of them. Such a shame. A damn shame.
Hope you all have a much better experience with this game. I feel like I've wasted 6 hours of my life.