A lot of this is subjective though, people have different tastes, so if you prefer something different, it doesn't mean that it is actually better. It's just your preference. All the whiskies you mention are high quality products produced in the tradition of their distilleries. They are all excellent.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO (in darth vadar voice)

I can't believe I missed the price drop on Lagavulin. Probably the first in history!!!

A lot of this is subjective though, people have different tastes, so if you prefer something different, it doesn't mean that it is actually better. It's just your preference. All the whiskies you mention are high quality products produced in the tradition of their distilleries. They are all excellent.

Yeah just downed them all in one day :laughing:

The highland park and dalwhinnie are very good prices

Great deal for Lagavulin. Just bought a bottle at duty free for £38 which I thought was a good deal. May need to buy another now though...

damn just bought a Singleton from amazon as it gave me free delivery for a lesser priced product :smirk:

Thanks, been waiting ages for the Lagavulin to drop in price.

Duplicate thread - http://www.hotukdeals.com/deals/amazon-whisky-deals-from-12-49-for-jim-beam-honey-bourbon-whisky-2579623

Lagavulin is temp out of stock. Gutted as I wanted it for Crimbo day.

The Lagavulin 16 yr is hardly ever discounted. Amazing deal on a great whisky :-)

Wow. The Lagavulin is an amazing whisky and amazing value here. Likewise the Caol Ila.

OMG. Lagavulin is never on offer let alone a huge discount like this . Had to buy one at that price and threw in a bottle of Makers Mark for £20 as well . The amount of offers is scary , I'm stocked up till next Xmas at this rate

Agree with OP today's discounts are pretty much all proper whiskies with exception of the flavoured Jim Beams. Great prices on Highland Park , Bulliet , Woodford, Taliskier as well. Also do not pass over Jim Beam Double Oak , that is a fine Bourbon and a steal at £17

Wow, five bottles of whisky on your birthday? You're hard core man :wink:

simply: it's not above

Laphroaig, Lagavulin & Ardbeg are the top 3 - age matters, price matters

Bowmore can do a good second place job but it'll never be in the top 3

Caol Ila and the others are third - not as good but pretty good

Agreed, I would put it above the Lagavulin.

For what it's worth, ie not much, my view is that Caol Ila is right up there with Lagavulin and Ardbeg. At least it was last time I tried it, which was a good while ago.

Argh i've already just had 5 bottles for my birthday and no doubt more to come at christmas, but I am tempted! Lagavulin is one of my favs and Caol Ila is one I have been meaning to try too. The more peat smoke the better!