Would this look good in bluray? Dvd looks terrible...
ChampEon to teggl97
27 Nov 151#7
This is one if the reviews from Amazon (I've highlighted the relevant bits):
" WARNING: If you're thinking of buying these films individually , just be cautious , as there are a couple of versions of Predator available on Blu-ray and one of them is just a basic transfer that HASN'T had the full treatment. The Ultimate Edition (The Ultimate Hunters Edition as Amazon likes to call it) is the one you want and what you get in this box set.
PREDATOR ULTIMATE EDITION : Right from the off with the old eighties 20th Century Fox logo you can immediately see the difference in picture quality.
Flecks of dust and scratches are completely gone and almost looks like a brand new print of the film and this is just from the first 20 seconds. Even the opening shot of the predator ship which separates , you used to be able to see matt outline boxes around both ships on the VHS , Laserdisc and DVD versions , which was always disappointing but this seems to have been completely removed which was a pleasant surprise.
Also a sun glare reflecting off the ships hull seems to have been added to the departing ship as it reaches the edge of the screen when it veers off to the right , but not sure if this has been an added element for the Blu-rays or if its just more noticeable now with the cleaned up image or the format change ? Have compared the two formats but just cant tell , as the ship disappears too soon on the DVD format , as that is presented in 18.5:1 , and even though on the Blu-ray case it says its presented in the same format , there is a noticeable difference in width compared to the DVD.
I have to say , the slightly wider format is much better as it cancels out a lot of glaring mistakes.
Dillon's arm being visible tucked in his pants when shot off and the springboard he's obviously standing on being in-shot when he finally dies.
A microphone above Mac's head when he says 'past dem treeeeeees' and Billy's rucksack seen bouncing on the floor under the tree when he drops it at his last stand (he's supposed to be over a very deep gorge) are now no where to be seen.
Although these appeared to be mistakes on previous releases , it was really down to seeing more of the top and bottom of the screen than you were supposed too , due to the format it was shown in and not down to dodgy camera work.
The whole film is superbly transferred with every frame razor sharp and contamination free and not a hint of "the grain effect" that some Blu-Rays suffer from , and you could literally count the beads of sweat on Bill Dukes head the picture is that good !
Cant believe just how dust contaminated and grainy the print was on DVD after viewing this Blu-ray and it just shows what can be achieved with a little effort , unlike some Blu-rays I could mention and have on other less favourable reviews !
The scene where Arnold abseils from the helicopter on all other formats suffered terribly with grain/grit , but this has been cleaned up beautifully on Blu-ray.
A couple of negatives... apart from the shot of the full moon in-between the trees just before the final showdown , it still has a very noticeable matt outline box around it and its a shame it hasn't been fixed , and Carl Weathers facial close up does tend to have a "waxy" look , but these minuscule blips are a very small price compared to the rest of this excellent transfer , and is up there with one of the best picture transfers I've seen.
Not much to say about the sound other than , excellent !
As for the extras , you get everything from the DVD plus a couple more ...Which was nice !
PREDATOR 2 : Think its universally agreed this is the weaker of the films so not going to mention too much about this other than the picture and sound are excellent and much better than its DVD format , but not as good a transfer as the first Predator.
Extras are exactly the same as the DVD... Which WASN'T nice !
PREDATORS : Well from a film that is only a couple of years old theres not really much to say about the picture/sound quality other than what you'd expect from a recent release.
Don't usually review the picture/sound quality on a Blu-ray if the film was made after 2006 , as the majority of films after that time are usually filmed with Blu-rays in mind and have the highest quality digital cameras filming them.
Depending on which version you bought on DVD (the single disc for me) you get loads more extras on this Blu-ray and all have digital copies as well... Which is very nice ! Definitely worthy of an upgrade working out at £5 per film , this is an EXCELLENT PURCHASE ! "
So yeah, looks like 3 good quality blu rays at a super low price. Thanks OP
Opening post
if it bleeds we can kill it
ultimate hunter edition too
8 comments
" WARNING: If you're thinking of buying these films individually , just be cautious , as there are a couple of versions of Predator available on Blu-ray and one of them is just a basic transfer that HASN'T had the full treatment.
The Ultimate Edition (The Ultimate Hunters Edition as Amazon likes to call it) is the one you want and what you get in this box set.
PREDATOR ULTIMATE EDITION : Right from the off with the old eighties 20th Century Fox logo you can immediately see the difference in picture quality.
Flecks of dust and scratches are completely gone and almost looks like a brand new print of the film and this is just from the first 20 seconds. Even the opening shot of the predator ship which separates , you used to be able to see matt outline boxes around both ships on the VHS , Laserdisc and DVD versions , which was always disappointing but this seems to have been completely removed which was a pleasant surprise.
Also a sun glare reflecting off the ships hull seems to have been added to the departing ship as it reaches the edge of the screen when it veers off to the right , but not sure if this has been an added element for the Blu-rays or if its just more noticeable now with the cleaned up image or the format change ? Have compared the two formats but just cant tell , as the ship disappears too soon on the DVD format , as that is presented in 18.5:1 , and even though on the Blu-ray case it says its presented in the same format , there is a noticeable difference in width compared to the DVD.
I have to say , the slightly wider format is much better as it cancels out a lot of glaring mistakes.
Dillon's arm being visible tucked in his pants when shot off and the springboard he's obviously standing on being in-shot when he finally dies.
A microphone above Mac's head when he says 'past dem treeeeeees' and Billy's rucksack seen bouncing on the floor under the tree when he drops it at his last stand (he's supposed to be over a very deep gorge) are now no where to be seen.
Although these appeared to be mistakes on previous releases , it was really down to seeing more of the top and bottom of the screen than you were supposed too , due to the format it was shown in and not down to dodgy camera work.
The whole film is superbly transferred with every frame razor sharp and contamination free and not a hint of "the grain effect" that some Blu-Rays suffer from , and you could literally count the beads of sweat on Bill Dukes head the picture is that good !
Cant believe just how dust contaminated and grainy the print was on DVD after viewing this Blu-ray and it just shows what can be achieved with a little effort , unlike some Blu-rays I could mention and have on other less favourable reviews !
The scene where Arnold abseils from the helicopter on all other formats suffered terribly with grain/grit , but this has been cleaned up beautifully on Blu-ray.
A couple of negatives... apart from the shot of the full moon in-between the trees just before the final showdown , it still has a very noticeable matt outline box around it and its a shame it hasn't been fixed , and Carl Weathers facial close up does tend to have a "waxy" look , but these minuscule blips are a very small price compared to the rest of this excellent transfer , and is up there with one of the best picture transfers I've seen.
Not much to say about the sound other than , excellent !
As for the extras , you get everything from the DVD plus a couple more ...Which was nice !
PREDATOR 2 : Think its universally agreed this is the weaker of the films so not going to mention too much about this other than the picture and sound are excellent and much better than its DVD format , but not as good a transfer as the first Predator.
Extras are exactly the same as the DVD... Which WASN'T nice !
PREDATORS : Well from a film that is only a couple of years old theres not really much to say about the picture/sound quality other than what you'd expect from a recent release.
Don't usually review the picture/sound quality on a Blu-ray if the film was made after 2006 , as the majority of films after that time are usually filmed with Blu-rays in mind and have the highest quality digital cameras filming them.
Depending on which version you bought on DVD (the single disc for me) you get loads more extras on this Blu-ray and all have digital copies as well... Which is very nice ! Definitely worthy of an upgrade working out at £5 per film , this is an EXCELLENT PURCHASE ! "
So yeah, looks like 3 good quality blu rays at a super low price. Thanks OP