Just got back from aldi in Peterborough and they had a action camera on offer previously priced at £39.99 then £29.99 but now down to £19.99. Not sure if nationwide but might be worthwhile checking your local store if your in the market for one. Very similar to the go pro type, but I'm not sure on the quality of the aldi one.
Top comments
wenttoabetterplace to ezzer72
20 Oct 153#14
True.
But then again, if money is that tight, should one really be fizzing it up the wall in order to invest in a ropey action cam? :smiley:
ezzer72
20 Oct 153#9
That's only 205% of the price, I'm with you on this mate :wink:
All comments (44)
tafkas
19 Oct 15#1
Which Aldi in Peterborough? There's three since the Hampton one opened recently.
jackjones68
19 Oct 151#2
none in south shields
Jupitor5
19 Oct 15#3
Hampton
mickgoodie to Jupitor5
20 Oct 15#38
at the posh game tonight, but I might drop over tomorrow if they have any left!
Jupitor5
19 Oct 15#4
Sorry I forgot about the others!!
dazco
19 Oct 15#5
great deal
wenttoabetterplace to dazco
19 Oct 15#6
Not really a great deal.
The Xiaomi Yi cam is only £41 - and has video resolutions up to 2K, and 60fps 1080P. It also has a top end processor & imaging sensor.
The only certainty with this Aldi camera is that the footage will be disappointing.
A false economy IMO
dazco
19 Oct 15#7
How is that a certainty?
wenttoabetterplace
20 Oct 151#8
720p makes it a near enough certainty that it will be a disappointment.
ezzer72
20 Oct 153#9
That's only 205% of the price, I'm with you on this mate :wink:
wenttoabetterplace
20 Oct 151#10
Why spend £20 on something that'll give you utterly forgettable footage, when you can spend an extra £20 on something that has video quality rivalling the GoPro Black editions!
The Yi camera really is remarkable for the money. It also has WiFi/Bluetooth for remote capture/playback.
This Aldi camera is just such a false economy.
wellayeman
20 Oct 151#11
I don't know much about these cameras but one thing is for sure, pixels doesn't mean a thing in terms of quality.
wenttoabetterplace to wellayeman
20 Oct 15#12
No, it doesn't...you are right there.
But the Xiaomi Yi camera has a 16 megapixel Sony Exmor R sensor, along with an Ambarella processor (same as in the GoPro's).
It is very much a premium combination. & 60 frames per second at 1080p for £41 is fantastic.
I'm sure you are right, honestly, and I tend to pay more for quality, but not everyone can afford to spend 205% on things.
There is a market for a product at different price points.
wenttoabetterplace to ezzer72
20 Oct 153#14
True.
But then again, if money is that tight, should one really be fizzing it up the wall in order to invest in a ropey action cam? :smiley:
ccparkhill to ezzer72
20 Oct 15#24
The Xiaomi is 105% more expensive than the Aldi.
adamcb to ezzer72
20 Oct 15#33
You have failed in every attempt to sway buyers and are doing a pretty poor job of selling this rubbish for the Aldi marketing team
darkstryder360
20 Oct 15#15
Xiaomi Yi looks good. Never heard of it. Personally use a Möbius Actioncam as its very discreet to use as a dashcam.
But that X Yi, 1080 60fps is pretty awesome for the price.
fish323
20 Oct 15#16
I had one of these and it lasted about a week.
scottydoobuy
20 Oct 15#17
where is this £41 best i can see on ebay or amazon is £53 ??? link plz
staceymills
20 Oct 15#18
Where did you find this camera at that price please? Thanks
spenspuma
20 Oct 15#19
YI is the one I'm going for...for the wifi alone.
xstrio
20 Oct 15#20
It's 42 on gear best including delivery
grimboj2
20 Oct 15#21
Is this really any good? I was gonna get sjcam 4000, what are you getting for £20?
bambulus
20 Oct 15#22
That X Yi deal is questionable. I'd much better recommend going through a company such as Amazon, raising the cost further - you then need to buy the waterproof housing as well.
Not saying it's not a better camera, it obviously is. It's just not really comparable to a £20 spend in Aldi.
FWIW, I think the Aldi cam looks like tat. Probably serviceable as a dash cam or to play around with, but not if you're after an 'action cam' that you want decent footage from.
Spend the money on an SJ Cam, which I have and is great, or the X Yi, which looks like a very good and more recent option. GoPro is the leader if you want brand assurance
We have the SJ4000 wifi and it's great value for the image quality. It's not as perfect (and who knows whether it will last as long) as a GoPro, but for the money, the SJ4000 is hard to beat. Having a screen on the back is essential, in my opinion. Wifi is useful for seeing what you're about to film, if you have it mounted somewhere you can't see with your own eyes.
Can't comment on the Aldi one I'm afraid but I would go for the SJ4000 if you can afford to.
Jakeway
20 Oct 15#25
I own a "Xiaomi Yi" cam. Its very good... But I had to replace the lens because my model was made without an IR filter. Also I had to refocus the lens because it was originally bluey. So as much as I like it, it was also a pain.
Oh... And its not made by Xiaomi, just sold on their store. So everyone uses their name now. Like saying M&S Goodfellas Pizza.
den169
20 Oct 151#26
I'll leave that then was hoping to go down and film the Titanic with it.
SVRich
20 Oct 151#27
Exactly 105% more, if you budget for the camera is £20 you are spending 100% (rounded) of that on the Aldi camera or 105% more of your budget for the Xiaomi which is 205% in total.
Also, keep in mind that the depth rating on a waterproof case is essentially referring to the sustained pressure that it can withstand. So if you jumped off a high dive board with a camera case that has a 10m depth rating, you'll probably far exceed the pressure rating of the case.
Having a camera enclosed in a dive case rated to 60 metres means your camera is far more likely to survive whatever you throw at it :smiley:
dona3853
20 Oct 151#31
I have one of these. It isn't great tbh. I used it on a mud run on Sunday and although it never went under water it fogged up inside the case very quickly. Ended up having to take it out of the case just to use it each time. It's ok for a toy but if you actually want decent footage then even for £20 it's pretty useless.
wenttoabetterplace to dona3853
20 Oct 151#32
If there is enough space to do so, try sticking in a silica gel sachet. Alternatively (less than ideal) rub some fairy liquid over the lens cover of the dive case. I do this on my mask when scuba diving to stop it fogging up.
stu83
20 Oct 15#34
I'll give you heat to counter some of the nonsense spouted on here.
couragenh
20 Oct 15#35
Meanwhile, three months from now. :man: I say, looks like you did a jolly good job buying a xiaomi cam. :sunglasses: thanks dude, the footage is awesome, unlike on the Aldi camera I bought the other time. :man: indeed old chap, that footage is utterly forgettable :sunglasses: what footage?
They both laugh, one orders a Guinness, the other Earl Grey.
wenttoabetterplace
20 Oct 15#36
Have you been earwigging my convos down at the Nags Head?!
:smile:
stanlenin
20 Oct 15#37
It's good to speak about something you don't know anything about. Xiaomi camera has terrible image quality. All blurry, no detail. Good 720p video would be better than what xiaomi has. SJ4000 has good iq.
Download the BangGood app & you can get 10% off your first purchase at BangGood (brings it down to just over £40). Choose the 23L version of the camera to get the must up to date version of the Yi camera.
cryptobrit
9 Nov 15#42
I've just bought the Kitvision Edge SD10 which comes with a waterproof case, a few attachments and detachable LCD back. Very pleased with it. I had previously bought the sj4000 and sent it back due to a 'white screen of death' and poorly made switches that were sticking. Although around the £107 mark, the quality of this is far better.
wenttoabetterplace to cryptobrit
9 Nov 15#43
Surely the Xiaomi for £43 would have been a better bet?! 2K video resolution and a top notch sensor/lens/processor combination.
cryptobrit
9 Nov 15#44
I did consider the Xiaomi as in the top 2 to 3 and it was a difficult decision. I knew about the excellent sensor but by the time I would have bought the extras such as the waterproof case, the costs would have mounted. I also didn't want to be totally reliant on using my iPhone as a viewer. Like most things in life there was 'fors' and 'againsts' and I made what is hopefully the right decision for me. Time will tell. I am still tempted to buy the Xiaomi next month but being the economist that I am and careful with money; at this point it is not a necessity:-).
Opening post
Top comments
But then again, if money is that tight, should one really be fizzing it up the wall in order to invest in a ropey action cam? :smiley:
All comments (44)
The Xiaomi Yi cam is only £41 - and has video resolutions up to 2K, and 60fps 1080P. It also has a top end processor & imaging sensor.
The only certainty with this Aldi camera is that the footage will be disappointing.
A false economy IMO
The Yi camera really is remarkable for the money. It also has WiFi/Bluetooth for remote capture/playback.
This Aldi camera is just such a false economy.
But the Xiaomi Yi camera has a 16 megapixel Sony Exmor R sensor, along with an Ambarella processor (same as in the GoPro's).
It is very much a premium combination. & 60 frames per second at 1080p for £41 is fantastic.
Also, keep in mind that this Aldi camera has been kicking around for at least 18 months. http://www.hotukdeals.com/deals/waterproof-action-camera-5mp-720p-44-99-aldi-15th-1899485
Oh, and its underwater case only goes down to 10 metres.
A recipe for disappointment :smiley:
There is a market for a product at different price points.
But then again, if money is that tight, should one really be fizzing it up the wall in order to invest in a ropey action cam? :smiley:
But that X Yi, 1080 60fps is pretty awesome for the price.
Not saying it's not a better camera, it obviously is. It's just not really comparable to a £20 spend in Aldi.
FWIW, I think the Aldi cam looks like tat. Probably serviceable as a dash cam or to play around with, but not if you're after an 'action cam' that you want decent footage from.
Spend the money on an SJ Cam, which I have and is great, or the X Yi, which looks like a very good and more recent option. GoPro is the leader if you want brand assurance
http://www.sjcam.com/cameras/27-sjcam-sj4000-wifi-1080p-full-hd-action-camera-sport-dvr.html
Can't comment on the Aldi one I'm afraid but I would go for the SJ4000 if you can afford to.
Oh... And its not made by Xiaomi, just sold on their store. So everyone uses their name now. Like saying M&S Goodfellas Pizza.
Apologies, it is now £42 :smiley:
http://www.hotukdeals.com/deals/original-xiaomi-yi-1080p-ambarella-a7ls-wifi-sports-action-camera-42-00-gearbest-2304163
Also, keep in mind that the depth rating on a waterproof case is essentially referring to the sustained pressure that it can withstand. So if you jumped off a high dive board with a camera case that has a 10m depth rating, you'll probably far exceed the pressure rating of the case.
Having a camera enclosed in a dive case rated to 60 metres means your camera is far more likely to survive whatever you throw at it :smiley:
:man: I say, looks like you did a jolly good job buying a xiaomi cam.
:sunglasses: thanks dude, the footage is awesome, unlike on the Aldi camera I bought the other time.
:man: indeed old chap, that footage is utterly forgettable
:sunglasses: what footage?
They both laugh, one orders a Guinness, the other Earl Grey.
:smile:
http://www.hotukdeals.com/deals/original-xiaomi-yi-1080p-ambarella-a7ls-wifi-sports-action-camera-42-00-gearbest-2304163
OR,
Download the BangGood app & you can get 10% off your first purchase at BangGood (brings it down to just over £40). Choose the 23L version of the camera to get the must up to date version of the Yi camera.