Got the integral one for under £24 and been fine so far, not sure if this is better for read/write speeds ?
topss to mackem1966
6 May 161#4
To be fair to the Integral (or most SSD's in this price range) I doubt most people under normal PC use will notice much difference, especially if switching from a mechanical drive. 3 year warranty on both is a bonus, but not sure how good either of the manufactures are on turn around.
spannerzone
6 May 161#3
Nice and the 3 year warranty is good.
Dannyrobbo
6 May 161#5
Toshiba developed the initial technology in the base level so I'd go for that...based on nothing else
Warranty is meaningless - if this is worth £30 now what do you think it'll cost in 3 years time? Good deal all the same
chapchap to ecosse87
6 May 163#7
it isn't meaningless at all.
topss to ecosse87
6 May 16#8
Probably won't be available to buy in 3 years time. Not sure why you think that's relevant to the warranty though.
fishmaster to ecosse87
7 May 161#12
OK so you buy this SSD and it fails on the same day do you
a: Go oh the warranty is meaningless and pay another £30
b. Get a replacement on the warranty.
If you choose a. how many times will you choose a. before you think I'm suspecting this warranty thing could be quite useful.
Also if you do either a. and b. many times let us know as the SSD is likely a dud product :smiley:
bill888
7 May 16#10
Granted that you are more likely to see people post bad reviews on Amazon. Nevertheless, the reviews don't look good on Amazon UK and USA. Very high percentage of 1 star reviews when compared to other SSDs sold by Amazon.
does not make sense, 240crucial and sandisk at less than £40 from time to time
captainbeaky
7 May 161#14
It £6.24 cheaper at £23.74 if you use promo code at mymemory (MM5FB).
Dannyrobbo
7 May 16#15
I love a bit of history, when you are buying other brands...you are really buying Toshiba :wink:
jukkie
7 May 16#16
Tried to sell a brand new boxed 480GB Q300 for £50 to someone in the wanted section yesterday, they turned me down.
I hate rejection :disappointed: .
Not sure about those Amazon reviews, I've installed a lot of Q300's over the last couple of Months and none have been reported faulty yet.
Maybe just a bad batch from Amazon?
taras
7 May 16#17
the q300 are basement bucket ssds..
jukkie to taras
7 May 16#20
It's still a massive improvement on HDD's for people wanting to upgrade.
ukez
7 May 162#18
The warranty is totally relevant.
You increase your chances of ending up with something better, or even newer if your device becomes faulty 2.5 years down the road and you've got a 3 year warranty, more so than you do with a one. As the manufacture will probably no longer stock the current version and will more than likely offer you a newer replacement if you're lucky. So you could effectively end up with the latest gen hardware further down the road for no additional cost. :laughing:
I've had newer replacement parts in the past from Samsung, Logitech and Microsoft.
If your thinking, well who's going to be using a 120GB SSD 3 years down the road, you will be surprised. People are still booting tiny operating systems like Xpenology, Slax, Puppy Linux, Freenas, pFsense and other small software using old Sata, IDE, USB and CF cards or whatever spares they've got lol.
Just because something becomes old it doesn't necessarily become redundant, just look at the fact that they still offer serial, parallel, PCI and PS2 ports on 2016 thin-itx motherboards and look how old those things are. :laughing:
DatAlbino
7 May 16#19
Save your money, spend another 15 or so quid and get an m.2 SSD, something like the Samsung 850 EVO, 120gb is around 50 quid and the speed is like 6gb/s, much better imo
jukkie to DatAlbino
7 May 16#21
You are presuming everyone has an m.2 slot?
3guesses to DatAlbino
10 May 16#24
Will the average user notice any real difference in the speed?
topss
7 May 16#22
Not sure in what context your were replying to me in.
The point of my reply was to ask what relevance does the warranty have to 'what do you think it will cost in 3 years time'. None whatsoever. Neither did I mention that people won't be using 120gb SSDs in 3 years time. But its likely this particular drive won't be available in 3 years time, making the above earlier quoted comment irrelevant.
But yes, a long warranty is a good thing, and yes, if it fails close to the end of warranty, it's likely it will be replaced by a newer model.
taras
8 May 16#23
only really on iops which mechanical drives can't match and never will do.
jukkie
10 May 16#25
The short answer: No.
The long answer: Noooooo.
3guesses
11 May 16#26
Not much reason to spend the extra money then 8-)
DatAlbino
15 May 16#27
Speed is speed man, an m.2 will be much faster than a HDD or SSD, just as a better SSD will be too. Theres a reason an Evo costs slightly more, its a top seller cos its super fast, super reliable, with a warranty from a global brand with excellent customer service
3guesses
15 May 16#28
Ah yes, the same reason I see loads of people pottering around town on their £10,000 carbon fibre racing bikes...
Opening post
Top comments
All comments (28)
a: Go oh the warranty is meaningless and pay another £30
b. Get a replacement on the warranty.
If you choose a. how many times will you choose a. before you think I'm suspecting this warranty thing could be quite useful.
Also if you do either a. and b. many times let us know as the SSD is likely a dud product :smiley:
link to Amazon UK reviews
link to Amazon US reviews
Integral SSD looks like a better buy imho.
I hate rejection :disappointed: .
Not sure about those Amazon reviews, I've installed a lot of Q300's over the last couple of Months and none have been reported faulty yet.
Maybe just a bad batch from Amazon?
You increase your chances of ending up with something better, or even newer if your device becomes faulty 2.5 years down the road and you've got a 3 year warranty, more so than you do with a one. As the manufacture will probably no longer stock the current version and will more than likely offer you a newer replacement if you're lucky. So you could effectively end up with the latest gen hardware further down the road for no additional cost. :laughing:
I've had newer replacement parts in the past from Samsung, Logitech and Microsoft.
If your thinking, well who's going to be using a 120GB SSD 3 years down the road, you will be surprised. People are still booting tiny operating systems like Xpenology, Slax, Puppy Linux, Freenas, pFsense and other small software using old Sata, IDE, USB and CF cards or whatever spares they've got lol.
Just because something becomes old it doesn't necessarily become redundant, just look at the fact that they still offer serial, parallel, PCI and PS2 ports on 2016 thin-itx motherboards and look how old those things are. :laughing:
The point of my reply was to ask what relevance does the warranty have to 'what do you think it will cost in 3 years time'. None whatsoever. Neither did I mention that people won't be using 120gb SSDs in 3 years time. But its likely this particular drive won't be available in 3 years time, making the above earlier quoted comment irrelevant.
But yes, a long warranty is a good thing, and yes, if it fails close to the end of warranty, it's likely it will be replaced by a newer model.
The long answer: Noooooo.