I bought a pack yesterday, weighed nearer to 1kg, and they were British Gala apples, small but nice and sweet.
Top comments
ka1rua
6 May 1611#8
im perfect frut and veg would normally be binned so buy doing this we get something cheap and they make money from what would be a complete loss.
im glad supermarkets are doing this food waste is very high i work in a bakery so i see it.
premierfella
6 May 163#7
Perfectly imperfect... hmmm, interesting use of the language from Tesco.
Why not just create another new fake "farm" label that differentiates them from the "perfect" stuff?
All comments (27)
3guesses
6 May 16#1
Ooh, fantastic. Thanks for the heads up. I prefer my apples imperfect anyway, I think! I'd also rather they were something like Russet rather than Gala (a bit too sweet?).
3guesses to 3guesses
7 May 16#26
None left in my local Tesco when I went yesterday evening 8-(
Hoping for better luck tonight 8-)
rikconnor
6 May 161#2
You cannot grow and pack apples for that price, so do we think Tesco or selling it for a loss, or is there a poor grower out there ?
otterboxer
6 May 162#3
Hmm selling seconds i dont have an issue with but marketing them as something special is plain silly and another reason why Tesco is floundering.
MajorCockUp to otterboxer
6 May 162#9
I always think that when i see cheap fresh produce. But then you take in account where it was farmed and how.
Ever tasted an apple from your own garden and realised supermarket fruit has nothing in common with real fruit? We should get over our prejudice towards home grown stuff that we call 'unfit for consume' just because it hasnt been sprayed or fed with poison.
Supermarket meat, fruit and veggies has nothing in common with real stuff. People who ate food from a real farm know what im talking about.
The_KELRaTH
6 May 161#4
I do think these rectangular apples are much easier to store :smiley:
patrober
6 May 16#5
Does that mean you cant download the lates iOS to them?
ElleJames
6 May 16#6
@kneale81 thanks for posting. I've never tried them before... May give them a go!
premierfella
6 May 163#7
Perfectly imperfect... hmmm, interesting use of the language from Tesco.
Why not just create another new fake "farm" label that differentiates them from the "perfect" stuff?
Mrepg to premierfella
7 May 16#16
Exactly, its not about wasting food its another marketing ploy.
ka1rua
6 May 1611#8
im perfect frut and veg would normally be binned so buy doing this we get something cheap and they make money from what would be a complete loss.
im glad supermarkets are doing this food waste is very high i work in a bakery so i see it.
defgimp to ka1rua
7 May 16#24
Hmmmm, don't disagree about the amount of food waste, but don't see how this reduces food loss/waste or makes any extra profit?
It's all marketing really :confused:
You simply move the waste/loss from source to retailer and then from retailer to consumer?
Mr A.Farmer has 10 tonne of apples that no one wants as they're shaped funny, so he has no choice but to bin them and take the loss.
Mr A.Supermarket bows to public opinion and decides to start selling said apples in his store at a substantial discount over his regular produce.
Mr A.Farmer can now go to the Caribbean as he's got pockets full of cash he didn't have last week?! :wink:
Mr A.Supermarket now has shelves full of apples that he's got to shift before they go mouldy.
Mrs A.Consumer comes along to do her shopping and notices that there's loads of apples available and they're soooo cheap compared to what she normally buys, so she buys twice as many, would be rude not to!
Even though Mr A.Supermarket has sold loads of apples, he's still got loads left!
His customers have bought twice as many apples as they normally do, but they've bought the cheap/imperfect ones and he's now got loads of perfect apples going rotten on his selves so he's going to bin them, take the loss :confused:
Meanwhile, Mrs A.Consumer has taken her shopping home and impressed everyone in the household with just how many apples she's bought for pence :wink:
A week later everyone in said household is sick of the sight of apples and stops eating them, they go mouldy and end up in the bin!
Mrs A.Consumer is now taking the loss/waste :confused:
In my humble opinion of course :smiley:
soldierboy001 to ka1rua
7 May 16#25
Get it right for gods sake, imperfect fruit and veg is not binned it is used depending on the product to make drink, ready meals and other such products that don't need to be perfect. Over purchase by customers provides more waste than would ever be allowed by manufacturers. They all find a way to use everything.
ethithrift
6 May 161#10
Got 12 in a bag last week so I can eat 3 at a time, which probably equates to 1 good sized fruit and it's still cheap :smiley: They don't even look substandard to me, and certainly taste OK.
joesmum
6 May 16#11
I may look for these as the 4 for £2 Pink Ladies apples I got from Sainsburys were rotten! First time that has happened.
Topsource
6 May 16#12
Good stuff. My hubby said they are the best he has tried. Well at least better than the gala one we paid £1.50 for. Supermarket should sell more of the so called cosmetically imperfect fruit and veg. I don't mind buying them, especially after watching the documentary that a British parsnip farmer ran out of business because of the harsh cosmetic standard from supermarkets(Morrison).
sandrabear
6 May 16#13
Not online what a shame
fishmaster
6 May 161#14
To the people moaning about Tesco's branding of this product, it's because most people want perfect looking fruit so most of you are to blame, so quit moaning!
The amount of food that goes to waste is criminal as evidenced earlier this year on Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall's documentary, in fact he found it hard to convince Morrison's to even sell imperfect produce and the marketing team looked like a bunch of tools on that program.
Let me get this straight, imperfect and full of chemicals. Apples being one fruit that absorbs them like no tomorrow. Yeah mate we sprayed these with tonnes of chems, but they still looked like they would come out bad, so we sprayed em a few times more. They turned out shocking, but we will sell em as imperfect! As if people are dull enough to believe imperfect means farm fresh organic gm free etc etc. Doh they do - have some ice.
rev6 to Mrepg
7 May 16#17
What would you call them, if you were selling them?
kneale81 to Mrepg
7 May 16#19
Haha why get so angry over apples? Chill.
fishmaster to Mrepg
7 May 161#20
Where is the implication that this item is farm fresh, organic, gm free? Come on actually quote from Tesco where they imply this or from the deal description etc.
We need more imperfect produce on sale, this is beneficial in a number of ways i.e. food wastage and economics (producer gets paid for a higher % of produce).
You may see this as marketing, however in this instance the marketing is good, it's there to say hey fickle consumers, yes you the ones that only want perfect looking fruit and veg, here's a way we've bundled this up differently so that you might accept buying it! Simple as that! The supermarkets have played a huge amount in our perception of what's acceptable, at least Tesco have started every so slightly to amend their ways. If this hits off then others will follow. Before supermarkets fruit and veg was imperfect, well of course it always has been, but supermarkets have the power to market produce how they feel it will best sell to the consumer. The consumer bares a huge brunt of how things are marketed to them, because it's their behaviour which modulates the marketing!
I find little credence in your argument. The gm, organic, farm fresh debate is completely separate from the debate on how to present cosmetically imperfect fruit and veg to the consumer. That's exactly what this deal is about and nothing to do with GM/Organic.
ipsa
7 May 16#18
Rare tesco deal
ashman33
7 May 16#21
Tesco getting desperate. I suppose it's good that they are 'imperfect'. I once bought a bag of Apples from Tesco that tasted like spuds.
rev6 to ashman33
7 May 16#27
Hmmm no.
david_james_kent
7 May 16#22
some of these went slimy by a few days don't buy if you want to keep for a few days
spudgun7
7 May 16#23
Asda, Morrisons and Waitrose are all selling "less than perfect" fruit and veg now.
The veg I've bought in Waitrose are as good as normal full priced stuff and cheaper. What's not to like?
Opening post
I bought a pack yesterday, weighed nearer to 1kg, and they were British Gala apples, small but nice and sweet.
Top comments
im glad supermarkets are doing this food waste is very high i work in a bakery so i see it.
Why not just create another new fake "farm" label that differentiates them from the "perfect" stuff?
All comments (27)
Hoping for better luck tonight 8-)
Ever tasted an apple from your own garden and realised supermarket fruit has nothing in common with real fruit? We should get over our prejudice towards home grown stuff that we call 'unfit for consume' just because it hasnt been sprayed or fed with poison.
Supermarket meat, fruit and veggies has nothing in common with real stuff. People who ate food from a real farm know what im talking about.
Why not just create another new fake "farm" label that differentiates them from the "perfect" stuff?
im glad supermarkets are doing this food waste is very high i work in a bakery so i see it.
It's all marketing really :confused:
You simply move the waste/loss from source to retailer and then from retailer to consumer?
Mr A.Farmer has 10 tonne of apples that no one wants as they're shaped funny, so he has no choice but to bin them and take the loss.
Mr A.Supermarket bows to public opinion and decides to start selling said apples in his store at a substantial discount over his regular produce.
Mr A.Farmer can now go to the Caribbean as he's got pockets full of cash he didn't have last week?! :wink:
Mr A.Supermarket now has shelves full of apples that he's got to shift before they go mouldy.
Mrs A.Consumer comes along to do her shopping and notices that there's loads of apples available and they're soooo cheap compared to what she normally buys, so she buys twice as many, would be rude not to!
Even though Mr A.Supermarket has sold loads of apples, he's still got loads left!
His customers have bought twice as many apples as they normally do, but they've bought the cheap/imperfect ones and he's now got loads of perfect apples going rotten on his selves so he's going to bin them, take the loss :confused:
Meanwhile, Mrs A.Consumer has taken her shopping home and impressed everyone in the household with just how many apples she's bought for pence :wink:
A week later everyone in said household is sick of the sight of apples and stops eating them, they go mouldy and end up in the bin!
Mrs A.Consumer is now taking the loss/waste :confused:
In my humble opinion of course :smiley:
The amount of food that goes to waste is criminal as evidenced earlier this year on Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall's documentary, in fact he found it hard to convince Morrison's to even sell imperfect produce and the marketing team looked like a bunch of tools on that program.
https://www.rivercottage.net/war-on-waste
We need more imperfect produce on sale, this is beneficial in a number of ways i.e. food wastage and economics (producer gets paid for a higher % of produce).
You may see this as marketing, however in this instance the marketing is good, it's there to say hey fickle consumers, yes you the ones that only want perfect looking fruit and veg, here's a way we've bundled this up differently so that you might accept buying it! Simple as that! The supermarkets have played a huge amount in our perception of what's acceptable, at least Tesco have started every so slightly to amend their ways. If this hits off then others will follow. Before supermarkets fruit and veg was imperfect, well of course it always has been, but supermarkets have the power to market produce how they feel it will best sell to the consumer. The consumer bares a huge brunt of how things are marketed to them, because it's their behaviour which modulates the marketing!
I find little credence in your argument. The gm, organic, farm fresh debate is completely separate from the debate on how to present cosmetically imperfect fruit and veg to the consumer. That's exactly what this deal is about and nothing to do with GM/Organic.
The veg I've bought in Waitrose are as good as normal full priced stuff and cheaper. What's not to like?